REPLACEMENT Explanatory Memorandum
(Circulated by the authority of the Treasurer the Hon John Dawkins, M.P.)CHAPTER THREE Sales Tax: Luxury Motor Vehicles
Summary of proposed amendments
Purpose of amendment: To change the effective rate of sales tax on luxury motor vehicles, so that:
- (a)
- the portion of the wholesale value that does not exceed the luxury threshold will be taxed at the general rate of sales tax applicable to that kind of motor vehicle (ie. either 16% or 21%, depending on the classification of the vehicle); and
- (b)
- a new rate of 45% will apply to the excess.
Date of effect: The change will apply to taxable dealings that occur with luxury motor vehicles on or after 18 August 1993.
Background to the legislation:
Under the existing law arrangements, luxury motor vehicles are subject to sales tax at a rate of 30% on their full wholesale value. A luxury motor vehicle is a passenger motor car or station wagon which has a wholesale value in excess of the luxury motor vehicle threshold. That threshold is calculated according to a formula that converts the motor vehicle depreciation limit (under the Income Tax law) to an equivalent wholesale value. For the 1993-94 financial year, the luxury motor vehicle threshold is $32,486.46.
Passenger motor cars or station wagons which have a wholesale value below the luxury motor vehicle threshold are taxable at either 15% or 20% (depending on the classification of the motor vehicle).
However, once the wholesale value of the motor vehicle exceeds the luxury threshold, the 30% rate is applied to the full wholesale value of the vehicle. This has the effect of imposing an additional 15% or 10% rate of tax (as the case may be), on the sub-luxury component of the wholesale value of the luxury motor vehicle. For example, the sales tax payable on a passenger vehicle with a wholesale value of $32,486 is $4,873, but if the wholesale value is increased by $1 to $32,487, the sales tax increases to $9,746.
Explanation of proposed amendments
The purpose of introducing the split rates is to remove the sudden increase in tax that is payable on the sub-luxury component of the wholesale value of a motor vehicle when it exceeds the luxury threshold. The split rate will mean that all passenger vehicles will be taxable at either 16% or 21% up to the current luxury threshold of $32,486.46. After the threshold has been reached, each additional dollar of wholesale value will be subject to tax at the rate of 45%. This means that where the luxury threshold is exceeded eg. by $1, the additional tax payable will be 45 cents rather than $4873 for 15% vehicles or $3249 for 20% vehicles.
The amendments will insert a new Schedule (Schedule 6) in the Sales Tax (Exemptions and Classifications) Act , which will apply sales tax at the rate of 45% on luxury motor vehicles. These are the same motor vehicles that are taxed under the existing law at 30%. [item 8 in schedule1 to clause 5;STEA,STGA and STCA]
However, for all taxable dealings with luxury motor vehicles, the new law will substitute a special taxable value. The effect of that special value will be to apply a split rate to luxury motor vehicles [clause 4, STAAM] :
- •
- the portion of the wholesale value of the motor vehicle that does not exceed the luxury threshold will be taxed at the general rate of sales tax applicable to that kind of motor vehicle (ie. 16% or 21%, depending upon the classification of the vehicle);
- •
- the portion of the wholesale value of the motor vehicle that does exceed the luxury threshold will be taxed at the new rate of 45%.
Example:
From the following information we can carry out a comparison between the reduced taxable value method used to calculate the taxable value proposed in the Bill, and the effective split value method, for a motor vehicle with a pre-luxury threshold classification which will be at a rate of 16%.
1993/4 Luxury motor vehicle depreciation limit: $48,415.00
Taxable value threshold: $32,486.46
Retail price of motor vehicle: $61,710.70
Equivalent wholesale value: $40,872.79
Split Rate 16%/45% Reduced Taxable Value 16% of $32,486.46 $5197.83 Taxable Value $40,872.79 45% of $8,368.33 $3773.85 Reduction $20,935.61 Tax payable $8,971.68 Reduced Taxable Value $19,937.18 Tax payable $8,971.73 Note: There is a minor variation which arises because the percentage figures specified in the law are rounded to the nearest third decimal point.
The amount of the reduction in the taxable value of a luxury vehicle will be calculated according to a formula:
- •
- In the case of motor vehicles of a kind ordinarily taxed at 16%, the formula will be [clause 4, STAAM] :
43.242% * Motor vehicle depreciation limit for the financial year in which the taxable dealing happens.- •
- In the case of motor vehicles of a kind ordinarily taxed at 21% (these are mainly off-road, four-wheel drive vehicles), the formula will be [clause 4, STAAM] :
35.787% * Motor vehicle depreciation limit for the financial year in which the taxable dealing happens.
While the more expensive luxury vehicles will not benefit from the change,vehicles which are presently priced just above the luxury wholesale value threshold of $32,486 will receive a significant sales tax benefit. For example, under the amendments the sales tax payable on a passenger vehicle taxable at the split rate of 16/45% which has a wholesale value of $32,500 will fall from $9750 to $5204. This saving will gradually decrease as the vehicle price increases because of the greater impact of the higher 45% rate. The tax benefit for a vehicle with a split rate of 16/45% and a wholesale value of $45,000 will only be $2671, the sales tax being reduced from $13,500 to $10829. The tax benefit will phase out when a vehicle has a retail price of just under $100,000. Vehicles sold at prices greater than $100,000 will incur more sales tax.
The percentages used to calculate the taxable value reduction for luxury motor vehicles will change on 1 July 1995 due to the general increase in all rates at that time. The new percentages will be 41.751% for vehicles to be taxed at the split rate of 17/45% and 34.296% for vehicles to be taxed at the split rate of 22/45%. [Schedule to clause 8, STAAM]
Luxury motor vehicles for disabled persons
There are two sales tax exemptions (Items 96 and 97, E & C Act) that allow certain disabled persons to purchase motor vehicles free of sales tax. The exemption is, however, only available for vehicles with a taxable value at or below the luxury motor vehicle threshold. If a person otherwise covered by Item 96 or 97 purchases a luxury motor vehicle, tax is payable on the vehicle. However, the taxable value of the vehicle is reduced.
Under the existing law, the effect of the reduction is to exclude, from the amount of the tax payable on the vehicle, the amount of tax that would be payable if the value of the vehicle did not exceed the luxury threshold. In calculating that amount, the law assumes in all cases that the vehicle would be taxed at the rate of 20%. However, in most cases, the vehicle would only be taxed at 15%. Consequently, a person can receive a reduction greater than the amount of tax that would have been payable if the vehicle had not exceeded the luxury limit.
Under the changes proposed by this Bill, the effect of the reduction is to exclude, from the amount of tax payable, the actual amount of tax that would have been payable if the value of the vehicle did not exceed the luxury threshold. Effectively, the vehicle is exempted from that part of the taxable value to which the rates of 16% and 21% apply. Tax is only payable on that part of the taxable value that exceeds the luxury motor vehicle threshold. The tax rate for the taxable part will be 45%. [clause 5, STAAM]
Example:
An eligible person purchases a vehicle with a wholesale value of $40,000. The wholesale taxable value for the application of the luxury motor vehicle tax is $32,486.46 and this part of the taxable value will be exempt. Tax will be payable at the rate of 45% on the difference between $40,000 and the luxury tax threshold of $32,486.46. Tax payable will be $3381.09 (45% of $7513.54).
With a split rate approach it is now possible to provide the same benefit to all eligible persons, whether the rate is 16/45% or 21/45%. Irrespective of the kind of passenger motor vehicle purchased, the first $32,486.46 of taxable value will be treated as exempt. After that each dollar of taxable value will be taxable at 45%.