ATO Interpretative Decision
ATO ID 2010/124
Income Tax
CGT event C1: sale of shares without the owner's consent - stockbroker's mistakeFOI status: may be released
This ATOID provides you with the following level of protection:
If you reasonably apply this decision in good faith to your own circumstances (which are not materially different from those described in the decision), and the decision is later found to be incorrect you will not be liable to pay any penalty or interest. However, you will be required to pay any underpaid tax (or repay any over-claimed credit, grant or benefit), provided the time limits under the law allow it. If you do intend to apply this decision to your own circumstances, you will need to ensure that the relevant provisions referred to in the decision have not been amended or repealed. You may wish to obtain further advice from the Tax Office or from a professional adviser.
Issue
Will CGT event C1 under section 104-20 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997) happen on the sale of shares in a company, without the consent of the owner of the shares, to a bona fide purchaser of the shares for value and without notice of the owner's lack of consent to the sale, as the result of a stockbroker's mistake?
Decision
Yes. The sale of shares without the owner's consent, to a bona fide purchaser of the shares for value and without notice of the owner's lack of consent to the sale, as the result of a stockbroker's mistake, means that the shares are lost and CGT event C1 will happen.
Facts
The taxpayer owned 10,000 shares in a company which they acquired after 19 September 1985. The shares were held in a stockbroker's account.
The taxpayer instructed their stockbroker to sell 1,000 of the shares.
The stockbroker mistakenly sold all 10,000 of the shares to a third party. The third party was a bona fide purchaser of the shares for value and without notice of the taxpayer's lack of consent to the sale. The taxpayer received a cheque for the sale proceeds of all 10,000 shares.
The sale of shares had settled by the time the stockbroker discovered the mistake.
To rectify the mistake, the stockbroker purchased 9,000 shares in the same company on behalf of the taxpayer. The original cheque issued to the taxpayer was cancelled, and the taxpayer received a new cheque for the sale proceeds of 1,000 shares.
Reasons for Decision
CGT event C1 happens if a CGT asset you own is lost or destroyed (subsection 104-20(1) of the ITAA 1997).
Shares are intangible CGT assets. Paragraph 7 of Taxation Determination TD 1999/79 states that
CGT event C1 does not distinguish between tangible and intangible assets. Section 104-20 refers to 'CGT asset' and this includes intangible CGT assets.
Paragraph 2 of Taxation Determination TD 1999/79 states that
The word 'lost' in its context in subsection 104-20(1) does not contemplate voluntary actions.
The 9,000 shares were sold to a third party without the taxpayer's consent. The taxpayer was involuntarily and permanently deprived of ownership of the 9,000 shares as the result of the unauthorised sale by another party to a third party who was a bona fide purchaser of the 9,000 shares for value and without notice of the taxpayer's lack of consent to the sale of the shares.
In all the circumstances, the 9,000 shares were 'lost' within the meaning of section 104-20 of the ITAA 1997. Therefore, CGT event C1 happened to the 9,000 shares.
CGT event A1 also happened on the sale of the 9,000 shares to a third party (disposal of a CGT asset - section 104-10 of the ITAA 1997). Under subsection 102-25(1) of the ITAA 1997, if more than one CGT event can happen to your situation, you use the one that is the most specific to your situation. In the circumstances, the most specific CGT event is CGT event C1.
The time of CGT event C1 is when compensation is first received for the loss. If no compensation is received, the time of the event is when the loss is discovered (subsection 104-20(2) of the ITAA 1997).
CGT event A1 happened in respect of the sale of the 1,000 shares which the taxpayer authorised.
Year of income: Year ended 30 June 2010
Legislative References:
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997
subsection 102-25(1)
section 104-10
section 104-20
subsection 104-20(1)
subsection 104-20(2)
Subdivision 124-B
Related Public Rulings (including Determinations)
Taxation Determination TD 1999/79
Keywords
Shares
CGT events C1-C3 - end of a CGT asset
Disposal of shares
ISSN: 1445-2782